Effect of different sand filter underdrain designs on emitter clogging using reclaimed effluents

Abstract

Sand media filters are those that achieve a higher retention of organic and inorganic solids, which is why they are usually recommended when reclaimed effluents are used in drip irrigation systems. Sand filters usually differ on the design of their underdrain, where an important pressure drop is produced. However, the effect of the design of sand filter underdrain on emitter clogging has not been widely studied. Three sand media filters with different underdrain designs (collector arms, inserted domes and drainage with porous media) were used for filtering a reclaimed effluent in a surface drip irrigation system. Pressure-compensating emitters with 2.3 l/h nominal emitter discharge were placed every 40 cm in 4 irrigation laterals each measuring 90 m in length. Effluents were chlorinated after being filtered. The filters operated for 1000 h with sand media heights of 20 and 30 cm and filtration velocities of 30 and 60 m/h. At the beginning, after 500 h, and at the end of the experiment the emitter discharge of each one of the 2712 emitters that were installed was experimentally measured under field conditions. On average, there was a statistically significant reduction (p < 0.05) on emitter discharge regarding the initial value of 8.03% at 500 h and 10.84% at 1000 h. Emitter clogging was primarily affected by the interactions between underdrain design, emitter location and irrigation time. Differences on emitter discharge due to underdrain design were only observed at 1000 h, showing a significantly higher flow rate (p < 0.05) those emitters protected with the filter with a collector arm underdrain, despite the fact that this filter did not achieve the highest turbidity removals. Emitter location had also a significant effect after 500 h of operation, being discharge significantly lower (p < 0.05) only in the last 2 m of the laterals, with the minimum values found for the final two drippers. The three filters used in the experiment did not show a significant effect on the percentage of completely clogged emitters, which mainly depended on the interaction between irrigation time and emitter location