Alternative ways to estimate change points in multinomial sequences. An application to an authorship attribution problem

DSpace/Manakin Repository

Show simple item record

dc.contributor Universitat de Girona. Departament d'Informàtica i Matemàtica Aplicada Riba, Alex Ginebra, Josep
dc.contributor.editor Thió i Fernández de Henestrosa, Santiago
dc.contributor.editor Martín Fernández, Josep Antoni 2003-10-17
dc.identifier.citation Riba, A.; Ginebra, J. 'Alternative ways to estimate change points in multinomial sequences. An application to an authorship attribution problem' a CODAWORK’03. Girona: La Universitat, 2003 [consulta: maig 2008]. Necessita Adobe Acrobat. Disponible a Internet a:
dc.identifier.isbn 84-8458-111-X
dc.description.abstract The statistical analysis of literary style is the part of stylometry that compares measurable characteristics in a text that are rarely controlled by the author, with those in other texts. When the goal is to settle authorship questions, these characteristics should relate to the author’s style and not to the genre, epoch or editor, and they should be such that their variation between authors is larger than the variation within comparable texts from the same author. For an overview of the literature on stylometry and some of the techniques involved, see for example Mosteller and Wallace (1964, 82), Herdan (1964), Morton (1978), Holmes (1985), Oakes (1998) or Lebart, Salem and Berry (1998). Tirant lo Blanc, a chivalry book, is the main work in catalan literature and it was hailed to be “the best book of its kind in the world” by Cervantes in Don Quixote. Considered by writters like Vargas Llosa or Damaso Alonso to be the first modern novel in Europe, it has been translated several times into Spanish, Italian and French, with modern English translations by Rosenthal (1996) and La Fontaine (1993). The main body of this book was written between 1460 and 1465, but it was not printed until 1490. There is an intense and long lasting debate around its authorship sprouting from its first edition, where its introduction states that the whole book is the work of Martorell (1413?-1468), while at the end it is stated that the last one fourth of the book is by Galba (?-1490), after the death of Martorell. Some of the authors that support the theory of single authorship are Riquer (1990), Chiner (1993) and Badia (1993), while some of those supporting the double authorship are Riquer (1947), Coromines (1956) and Ferrando (1995). For an overview of this debate, see Riquer (1990). Neither of the two candidate authors left any text comparable to the one under study, and therefore discriminant analysis can not be used to help classify chapters by author. By using sample texts encompassing about ten percent of the book, and looking at word length and at the use of 44 conjunctions, prepositions and articles, Ginebra and Cabos (1998) detect heterogeneities that might indicate the existence of two authors. By analyzing the diversity of the vocabulary, Riba and Ginebra (2000) estimates that stylistic boundary to be near chapter 383. Following the lead of the extensive literature, this paper looks into word length, the use of the most frequent words and into the use of vowels in each chapter of the book. Given that the features selected are categorical, that leads to three contingency tables of ordered rows and therefore to three sequences of multinomial observations. Section 2 explores these sequences graphically, observing a clear shift in their distribution. Section 3 describes the problem of the estimation of a suden change-point in those sequences, in the following sections we propose various ways to estimate change-points in multinomial sequences; the method in section 4 involves fitting models for polytomous data, the one in Section 5 fits gamma models onto the sequence of Chi-square distances between each row profiles and the average profile, the one in Section 6 fits models onto the sequence of values taken by the first component of the correspondence analysis as well as onto sequences of other summary measures like the average word length. In Section 7 we fit models onto the marginal binomial sequences to identify the features that distinguish the chapters before and after that boundary. Most methods rely heavily on the use of generalized linear models
dc.description.sponsorship Geologische Vereinigung; Universitat de Barcelona, Equip de Recerca Arqueomètrica; Institut d’Estadística de Catalunya; International Association for Mathematical Geology; Patronat de l’Escola Politècnica Superior de la Universitat de Girona; Fundació privada: Girona, Universitat i Futur.
dc.format.mimetype application/pdf
dc.language.iso eng
dc.publisher Universitat de Girona. Departament d’Informàtica i Matemàtica Aplicada
dc.rights Tots els drets reservats
dc.subject Estil literari -- Mètodes estadístics
dc.title Alternative ways to estimate change points in multinomial sequences. An application to an authorship attribution problem
dc.type info:eu-repo/semantics/conferenceObject

Files in this item


Show simple item record

Search DUGiDocs


My Account


views icon 917 downloads icon 348


This file is restricted

The file you are attempting to access is a restricted file and requires credentials to view. Please login below to access the file.

  1. We will contact you via the email address you have provided us.

Request a copy

When filling up the form you are requesting to the author or main author a copy of his/her article, which is stored in the institutional repository (DUGiDocs). Author decides himself/herlself whether it is appropiate to deliver a copy of the document to the requester or nott. In any case, the Library of the UdG doesn't participate in the process, as it isn't allowed to deliver any restricted articles.